ISP Chief Executives Attack Mandelson’s Filesharing Plans

Peter Mandelson’s sudden conversion to disconnecting filesharers from the internet to get the ‘problem’ of p2p under control has been attacked by chief executives of Britain’s internet service providers (ISP):

In a letter to The Times, Charles Dunstone of TalkTalk, Ian Livingston of BT and Tom Alexander of Orange UK criticised the proposals on how to reduce illegal filesharing announced last month, which include the possibility of disconnecting accounts.

The letter, also signed by Deborah Prince of Which?, Ed Mayo of Consumer Focus and Jim Killock of the Open Rights Group, said innocent consumers would suffer.

The letter itself reads as follows:

Consumers must be presumed to be innocent unless proven guilty. We must avoid an extrajudicial “kangaroo court” process where evidence is not tested properly and accused broadband users are denied the right to defend themselves against false accusations. Without these protections innocent customers will suffer. Any penalty must be proportionate. Disconnecting users from the internet would place serious limits on their freedom of expression. Usually, constraints to freedom of expression are imposed only as the result of custodial sentences, or incitement to racial hatred, or libel.

A point very nicely put. Mandelson’s plans represent the same problem posed by the Independent Safeguarding Authority – they are the equivalent of a sledgehammer to crack a nut, benefit entirely the wrong people, and would have side effects – most notably (in both cases) of undermining the rule of law. It’s heartening to see these people bringing the issue back to that, because ahead of any other transgression, it’s the undermining of the rule of law which remains this government’s most appalling achievement. Join us in fighting to stop it, and join me at the Pirate Party UK’s first public meeting this Saturday at 5.30pm in London.

Tags: BT, Charles Dunstone, Consumer Focus, Deborah Prince, Digital Britain, Ed Mayo, filesharing, Ian Livingston, internet, internet service provider, ISP, Jim Killock, Lord Mandelson, Open Rights Group, Orange UK, P2P, Peter Mandelson, Talk Talk, Tom Alexander, Which?

Related posts:

1. Filesharing: Mandelson Aims For Absolute Power Peter Mandelson has gone a step too far: Secretary of...
2. The Government Plans to Cut Your Internet Off The battle lines are being drawn. In June the government’s...
3. The Digital Economy Bill Must Not Pass Jim Killock summarises the case against Peter Mandelson’s Digital Economy...
4. Parliamentary Human Rights Committee vs Digital Economy Bill From Open Rights Group: Jim Killock, 05 February 2010 The...
5. The Digital Economy Bill is an Attack on the Rule of Law The opponents are beginning to line up against Peter Mandelson’s...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.